How Could Immigrant Voters Impact Elections?

Person holding American flag out of the window

More immigrants are naturalizing and becoming eligible to vote. Where they live and vote will have significant implications for swing districts in elections to come.

Every year hundreds of thousands of immigrants choose to naturalize, becoming American citizens and earning the right to vote. This growing population of immigrant voters has major implications for elections--particularly in critical swing districts that may help decide which party controls the House of Representatives.

Much has already been written about how voters turned off by anti-immigrant rhetoric helped Democrats gain control of the House in 2018. Less recognized, however, is how immigrants have played a role in some of these victories, and how their increasing numbers may position them to decide or sway elections going forward.

In 2018, 37 districts that experts had labeled as battlegrounds—areas that could be reasonably won by either major political party—flipped.

Democrats were able to win 35 of those seats. Meanwhile, just two of the tossup districts shifted from blue to red for Republicans.

In many of these swing districts, the immigrant vote is already large enough to impact election outcomes.

Of the 27 districts that flipped in the 2018 House elections, 34 saw an increase in their number of immigrant voters.

The voting clout of immigrants is growing rapidly in swing districts overall.

Excluding recently redrawn districts, the nonpartisan Cook Political Report labeled 66 districts total as battlegrounds in 2018. Using data from the U.S. Census to forecast the how the electorate will continue to evolve, by 2024, almost 20 of those districts—or close to a third of them—will have more new immigrant voters than the margin of victory in the 2018 House election.

This isn’t just a battleground issue; it’s a national one.

Since 2006, the number of immigrant voters has grown by nearly 5 million people. This has implications far beyond Congressional elections. After all, only one presidential election has been decided by more than 5 million votes since 2000.

The bottom line is simple.

America’s electorate is rapidly changing, particularly in swing districts. Although districts will be redrawn in many states after 2020, the demographic changes are so significant and inevitable that both parties will need to adapt to them. This has serious implications for politicians who have relied on anti-immigrant messages to appeal to voters. As NAE has found before, candidates will find it harder to convince increasingly diverse and college-educated electorates to vote for them with xenophobic platforms.

Of course, our 2024 figures are not written in the stars. After all, immigrant voters could well reverse recent electoral trends and vote for more Republican candidates. However, this is unlikely without Republicans embracing more inclusive rhetoric and championing the kind of sensible immigration reforms that are supported by the majority of Americans.

Margin of Victory for the past 5 presidential elections

Get the latest from NAE

Enter your information below to join NAE’s email list. We’ll only send you top-quality insights about immigration plus occasional opportunities to take action or get involved locally.

About Us

New American Economy brings together more than 500 mayors and business leaders who support immigration reforms that will help create jobs for Americans today. More…